Management Assessment Leads to Action and Improved ROI

By Leslie S. Pratch

A good management assessment can help you understand the personbehind the more easily observable track record and activities. Below is a much-abbreviated version of an actual report I sent to the investors who had hired me to assess a potential CEO whom I call “Mack.” It will give you a flavor for the difference the assessment can make in maximizing ROI (and minimizing anxiety in investors).


Mack had turned around underperforming operations but had never been CEO. His 25-year industry record looked good to the investors who had bought a large, family-owned company with plans for dramatically improving its performance.

The investors were concerned, though, about Mack’s ability to lead a billion dollar business. And they were interested in how he would work with the founding brothers (who would stay as operating executives) and other top managers through the wrenching change program.


The investors addressed Mark’s deficiencies, and his style and their guidance proved an effective combination in a turnaround situation. Investors created the strategy and told him to implement. They also monitored his impact on the organization, stepping in to communicate changes in ways others could accept. His implementation of an aggressive strategic plan yielded costs savings and revenue enhancements. The strategy and Mack’s outstanding, focused execution transformed the company into attractive platform on which to build a national competitor.

Four years after hiring Mack, investors sold the company to a financial sponsor. They called the investment “a home run,” having earned a return of 4.4 times their invested capital.

Conclusions that can be drawn

The assessment provided investors insight and confidence about what it would take for Mack to succeed. They understood what they needed to do, based on Mack’s managerial strengths and weaknesses. That awareness led them to provide him strategy in bite-size pieces he could implement, and to mitigate the effects of his hard-charging style.

A version of this story was originally published in The European Financial Review.

About the Author

Leslie S. Pratch is the founder and CEO of Pratch & Company. A clinical psychologist and MBA, she advises private equity investors, management committees and Boards of Directors of public and privately held companies whether the executives being considered to lead companies possess the psychological resources and personality strengths needed to succeed. In her recently published book, Looks Good on Paper? (Columbia University Press, 2014), she shares insights from more than twenty years of executive evaluations and offers an empirically based approach to identify executives who will be effective within organisations — and to flag those who will ultimately very likely fail — by evaluating aspects of personality and character that are hidden beneath the surface.

President and CEO of Pratch & Company, Leslie Pratch draws on 20 years of experience advising private equity investors and executives.